5. 12. 2022

ÚS: Městský soud se dopustil chyby, když obviněného nepoučil o možnosti podat dovolání k Nejvyššímu soudu

Obviněný byl uznán vinným přečinem zanedbání povinné výživy za což byl odsouzen k trestu odnětí svobody v trvání pěti měsíců.

Obžalovaný se odvolal proti rozsudku k Městskému soudu. Ten jej zamítl jako nedůvodné. V poučení usnesení uvedl, že proti tomuto usnesení není další řádný opravný prostředek přípustný. 

Odsouzený se následně obrátil na Ústavní soud. 

Odsouzený v ústavní stížnosti mimo jiné namítl, že nebyl poučen o možnosti podat dovolání proti usnesení městského soudu k soudu Nejvyššímu, čímž mu byla odepřena možnost bránit se tímto opravným prostředkem. 

Obviněný zároveň požádal o přiznání odkladného účinku. To odůvodnil tak, že není pro veřejnost nebezpečný a  odklad výkonu trestního rozhodnutí by mu umožnil vyvinout maximální aktivitu pro splácení běžného a dlužného výživného, pro jehož opakované neplacení byl nepodmíněně odsouzen. O odložení vykonatelnosti napadeného usnesení však Ústavní soud samostatně nerozhodoval, neboť o ústavní stížnosti samotné rozhodl v krátké době po jejím podání.

Ústavní soud se v této věci zaměřil především na otázku, zda se městský soud dopustil chyby, když obviněného nepoučil o možnosti podat dovolání k Nejvyššímu soudu. 

Po přezkoumání došel k závěru, že není chyba obviněného, že jej soud chybně poučil o opravném prostředku a není možné, aby za to nesl následky. Obviněnému tím totiž byla odepřena možnost podat dovolání. 

Městský soud tím, že stěžovatele nepoučil o možnosti podat dovolání, porušil jeho právo na soudní ochranu podle čl. 36 odst. 1 Listiny, a proto Ústavní soud v souladu se svou předchozí judikaturou a s § 82 odst. 1 a odst. 3 písm. a) zákona o Ústavním soudu ústavní stížnosti stěžovatele vyhověl a usnesení městského soudu zrušil. Městský soud je v novém rozhodnutí povinen stěžovatele náležitě poučit o jeho právu podat dovolání k Nejvyššímu soudu. 

Celý nález zde.

Diskuze (163) Vstoupit do diskuze

Vložit příspěvek

  1. Charlossaf napsal:

    You definitely made your point. https://definitionessays.com/ quest ut homework

  2. AlvenBrigo napsal:

    Thanks! An abundance of information!
    write my essay writing a personal essay

  3. Abrahamstore napsal:

    Cheers, A good amount of information!
    how to write a persuasive essay for kids paper writing best dissertation

  4. Wendellmon napsal:

    Lovely material, Appreciate it!
    best canadian online pharmacy on line pharmacy prescription drugs online without

  5. BruceZerce napsal:

    You expressed this wonderfully.
    canadapharmacy prescription drug cost mexican pharmacies

  6. Alvinhig napsal:

    Superb stuff. Regards.
    how to write a literary analysis essay https://flowleadsua.com/ professional writing help

  7. Alvinhig napsal:

    With thanks! Plenty of postings.
    how to write a letter essay essay writer help writing a book

  8. Wendellmon napsal:

    Whoa all kinds of valuable data!
    online pharmacy school pharmacy my canadian pharmacy

  9. Alvinhig napsal:

    Good material. Thanks a lot.
    Who wants to write my essay college essays help me write my thesis

  10. Alvinhig napsal:

    You made your point.
    paid to write essays steps to write an argumentative essay proposal writing services

  11. Alvinhig napsal:

    Truly many of valuable facts.
    college transfer essay essay rewriter phd thesis writing services

  12. Wendellmon napsal:

    Cheers, Plenty of info.
    no prescription pharmacies northwest pharmacy cialis generic pharmacy online

  13. Alvinhig napsal:

    Fantastic knowledge. Appreciate it!
    essay writing help essay typer thesis writing service reviews

  14. Alvinhig napsal:

    Well expressed truly. !
    how to write a essay about myself essay writing service custom writing bay

  15. Wendellmon napsal:

    With thanks. Useful information!
    best canadian pharmacies costco pharmacy pricing buy generic viagra online

  16. Alvinhig napsal:

    Cheers! I like it!
    what to write for college essay https://essaywriting4you.com/ business letter writing service

  17. Alvinhig napsal:

    Superb information. Thanks a lot!
    how to write a body paragraph for an essay college essay what is the best custom essay writing service

  18. Alvinhig napsal:

    Terrific forum posts. Appreciate it!
    help me essay https://essayssolution.com/ article rewriting services

  19. Wendellmon napsal:

    Info well regarded..
    best non prescription online pharmacies canadian pharmacies top best canadian prescriptions

  20. BruceZerce napsal:

    You actually suggested that wonderfully.
    prescription drugs from canada online modafinil online pharmacy prescription drugs online without

  21. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually said that perfectly.
    how to write a good essay introduction essay writing service essay writer website

  22. Alvinhig napsal:

    You expressed it well!
    why i want to attend college essay essay writing services singapore coursework writing help

  23. Wendellmon napsal:

    Thank you, Wonderful information!
    ed meds online without doctor prescription prescription drugs canada canadian pharmacies without an rx

  24. BruceZerce napsal:

    Excellent content. Kudos!
    cheap drugs mexican pharmacies shipping to usa pharmacy cheap no prescription

  25. Alvinhig napsal:

    Cheers. Numerous material.
    writing a narrative essay write my essays custom dissertation writing service

  26. Wendellmon napsal:

    Nicely put, Kudos.
    fda approved canadian online pharmacies canadian online pharmacies 24 hour pharmacy

  27. BruceZerce napsal:

    Perfectly spoken of course. .
    discount prescription drugs online northwest pharmacy/com canadian online pharmacies legitimate by aarp

  28. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks. Plenty of tips!
    college personal essay essay writer help writing a personal statement

  29. Alvinhig napsal:

    Great data. Thank you.
    essay writing jobs https://englishessayhelp.com/ custom writing company

  30. Wendellmon napsal:

    Cheers! I enjoy this.
    drug stores near me buy cialis meds online

  31. BruceZerce napsal:

    Fantastic info. Regards!
    canada drug prices pharmacy intern medicine online order

  32. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually stated this terrifically!
    writing better essays essay writer writing website

  33. BruceZerce napsal:

    Information very well regarded.!
    canadian pharmacies online prescriptions pharmacy online shopping online discount pharmacy

  34. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put, Regards!
    assignment essay help essay typer business plan writers nyc

  35. Wendellmon napsal:

    Really a lot of beneficial data.
    order medicine online canadian pharmaceuticals best canadian online pharmacy

  36. BruceZerce napsal:

    Truly many of fantastic facts!
    discount canadian drugs northwestpharmacy online pharmacy viagra

  37. Alvinhig napsal:

    Seriously a good deal of amazing info!
    writing an expository essay write and essay write my thesis for me

  38. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put. With thanks.
    english essay writer write my essay custom writing

  39. Wendellmon napsal:

    You have made your position pretty well.!
    drug price generic viagra online canadian pharmacy uk delivery

  40. BruceZerce napsal:

    Amazing information. Thanks.
    rx pharmacy generic viagra online pharmacy discount pharmaceuticals

  41. Alvinhig napsal:

    You suggested it very well.
    college goals essay college essays hiring a writer

  42. Alvinhig napsal:

    With thanks, I appreciate it.
    why is it important to go to college essay essay writer expert writing services

  43. Wendellmon napsal:

    Nicely put, Thank you.
    buy prescription drugs online canada pharmacies online prescriptions online pharmacy no prescription needed

  44. BruceZerce napsal:

    You actually revealed that well.
    canadian pharmacies online canadian online pharmacy reviews canada drugs

  45. Alvinhig napsal:

    Thanks, Ample information.
    essay about writing essay writings executive resume writing service seattle

  46. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually said it very well.
    essay formats for college https://homeworkcourseworkhelps.com/ essay writing service canada

  47. Wendellmon napsal:

    Regards! I value this!
    best canadian prescription prices canadian pharmacies-24h online pharmacies

  48. BruceZerce napsal:

    Well voiced indeed. !
    24 hour pharmacy international pharmacies that ship to the usa ed meds online without doctor prescription

  49. Alvinhig napsal:

    Really many of fantastic data!
    successful college essays website for essays in english how to find a ghostwriter

  50. Wendellmon napsal:

    Appreciate it. Lots of knowledge!
    canada pharmacy ed meds online medical information online

  51. Alvinhig napsal:

    Thanks! Lots of info.
    how to write a thesis sentence for an essay https://essaypromaster.com/ best resume writers nyc

  52. BruceZerce napsal:

    Great postings. Regards.
    canada drugs online pharmacy online drugstore pharmacy canadian prescriptions

  53. Alvinhig napsal:

    This is nicely expressed! .
    buy cheap essay online how to write an essay about a person newsletter writing service

  54. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually revealed it perfectly.
    essay for college scholarship https://dissertationwritingtops.com/ assignment writer

  55. Wendellmon napsal:

    Thanks! An abundance of information!
    canadian pharmacy overseas pharmacies canadian pharmacy certified canada pharmacy online

  56. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put, Thanks!
    help writing an essay https://homeworkcourseworkhelps.com/ custom coursework writing

  57. Alvinhig napsal:

    Superb tips. Thanks.
    mit college essays college essay help nyc letter writing service online

  58. Alvinhig napsal:

    You’ve made the point.
    essay writing prompts for high school write my essay academic writing services

  59. Wendellmon napsal:

    Great data, Thank you.
    fda approved canadian online pharmacies discount pharmacy canada drugs direct

  60. BruceZerce napsal:

    Seriously all kinds of useful facts.
    canadian online pharmacy reviews fda approved canadian online pharmacies canada drugs pharmacy online

  61. Alvinhig napsal:

    You expressed this superbly!
    leadership college essays how to write an argumentative essay write my thesis

  62. Alvinhig napsal:

    You suggested this well.
    what is a hook in writing an essay https://quality-essays.com/ how to find a ghostwriter

  63. Wendellmon napsal:

    Kudos! I enjoy this!
    canadian pharmacy king canadian pharmacies that are legit canadian pharmacies

  64. Alvinhig napsal:

    Regards, Awesome information!
    how to write a comparative essay https://freshapps.space/ websites for essays in english

  65. Wendellmon napsal:

    Nicely put. Regards.
    canadia online pharmacy mail order pharmacy generic viagra online pharmacy

  66. Alvinhig napsal:

    Regards, An abundance of information!
    writing a good college application essay https://altertraff.com/ cheap essay writing service us

  67. Alvinhig napsal:

    You reported that well!
    best college admission essays best custom essay writing service custom report writing service

  68. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually said it fantastically!
    best college essay writing services essaytyper best writing service reviews

  69. Wendellmon napsal:

    Excellent facts. Appreciate it.
    canadian prescription drugs mexican border pharmacies pain meds online without doctor prescription

  70. Alvinhig napsal:

    Wow all kinds of very good information.
    how to write an easy essay writing my essay academic writers online review

  71. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks, I value it.
    best custom essays me as a writer essay hire ghostwriter

  72. BruceZerce napsal:

    You actually mentioned it exceptionally well.
    discount prescription drug cheap canadian drugs drugstore online shopping

  73. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put. With thanks.
    top 10 essay writing services https://englishessayhelp.com/ custom writing tips

  74. Alvinhig napsal:

    You definitely made the point!
    essay revision service https://agbsl.pro/ essay writer website

  75. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually mentioned this adequately.
    writing an essay help write my essay christian ghostwriting services

  76. Wendellmon napsal:

    With thanks. I value this.
    online drugstore mexican online pharmacies canadianpharmacy

  77. BruceZerce napsal:

    Amazing stuff, Thanks.
    walgreens pharmacy london drugs canada canadian family pharmacy

  78. Alvinhig napsal:

    You suggested this very well!
    learning how to write essays write my essay cheap essay writing service us

  79. Alvinhig napsal:

    Cheers! An abundance of info.
    writing a five paragraph essay buy cheap essay online professional writing service

  80. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually explained it really well.
    custom essay company how to write an opinion essay professional resume writing service

  81. Wendellmon napsal:

    Kudos, A lot of data!
    doctor prescription most reliable canadian pharmacies canada pharmacy

  82. BruceZerce napsal:

    Nicely put. Thanks a lot!
    prescription drug cost north west pharmacy canada best non prescription online pharmacies

  83. Alvinhig napsal:

    Really quite a lot of beneficial info.
    college essay leadership essay writing service help with handwriting

  84. Alvinhig napsal:

    Amazing many of superb advice!
    buy essay papers cheap https://writingthesistops.com/ writers wanted

  85. Wendellmon napsal:

    You actually said it superbly.
    shoppers pharmacy canadian pharmacy without prescription viagra online canadian pharmacy

  86. Alvinhig napsal:

    You suggested this exceptionally well.
    high school essay help essay writing services cheap assignment writing service

  87. BruceZerce napsal:

    Awesome information. Thanks a lot.
    pharmacies in canada online pharmacy school drugs from canada with prescription

  88. Alvinhig napsal:

    Factor well regarded!.
    how to write an effective essay college essays case study writing service

  89. Wendellmon napsal:

    Many thanks! An abundance of posts.
    prescription drugs online without online pharmacies legitimate pharmacy price comparison

  90. BruceZerce napsal:

    Very good content, Many thanks!
    generic viagra online pharmacy best 10 online canadian pharmacies best online pharmacies canada

  91. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually expressed that adequately.
    how to write a professional essay custom essay paper writing personal statement writing service

  92. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put, With thanks!
    me as a writer essay https://orangepornhub.com/ help with writing dissertation

  93. Wendellmon napsal:

    Incredible lots of wonderful tips.
    pharmacy technician classes online free online pharmacy drugstore canada pharma limited

  94. KeithBip napsal:

    Appreciate it! Loads of knowledge.
    target pharmacy hours online canadian pharmacy 24 rx plus pharmacy

  95. Renaldoenala napsal:

    Really many of great material!

  96. KeithBip napsal:

    This is nicely expressed! .
    list of reputable canadian pharmacies online pharmacy technician certification program reputable canadian pharmacy site order prescriptions

  97. ThomasAxiof napsal:

    Many thanks, I like it!
    Levitra Professional cheapest canadian pharmacies check canadian pharmacies website

  98. KeithBip napsal:

    Fantastic info, Appreciate it.
    canadian association of pharmacies prescription drugs finder insulin from canadian pharmacies

  99. Antoniocrilm napsal:

    Whoa lots of superb tips!
    prescription drugs facts community pharmacy best canadian pharmacy to buy viagra

  100. Wilfordben napsal:

    You actually mentioned it really well!
    canadian pharma companies reputable canadian pharmacies online pharmacy course online

  101. Antoniocrilm napsal:

    Terrific content. Regards!
    online pharmacy degree programs walmart online pharmacy canadian no prescription pharmacy

  102. KeithBip napsal:

    Thanks! An abundance of data.
    promo code for canadian pharmacy meds pharmacy order online medications with no prescription

  103. Stanleyelumn napsal:

    You actually expressed it effectively!
    rx reliable pharmacy lipitor canadian pharmacy online pharmacy tech program

  104. KeithBip napsal:

    Seriously quite a lot of terrific tips.
    cheap cialis online canadian pharmacy singapore online pharmacy most abused prescription drugs

  105. Davidnum napsal:

    Reliable data. Kudos!
    overseas pharmacy canada pharma limited llc pharmacy technician jobs

  106. KeithBip napsal:

    You mentioned this very well!
    neighbor rx pharmacy is it safe to buy prescription drugs from canada canadian pharmacy generic cialis

  107. KeithBip napsal:

    Amazing postings. Thanks.
    pharmacy rx one online pharmacy people’s pharmacy pet meds canada pharmacy

  108. MichaelMogix napsal:

    Awesome posts. Thanks!
    online international pharmacy can i buy prescription drugs from canada reliable rx pharmacy coupon code

  109. KeithBip napsal:

    You actually revealed that superbly!
    legal online pharmacy coupon code best online pharmacies without prescription can americans buy prescription drugs from canada

  110. RichardCit napsal:

    Thanks! I like this.
    cheap ed drugs best online pharmacy for cialis rx crossroads pharmacy phone number

  111. KeithBip napsal:

    With thanks, I appreciate this.
    skin care does rx pharmacy coupons work canadian online pharmacy for viagra

  112. RichardCit napsal:

    Very good content. Many thanks.
    how to start a pharmacy store canada pharmaceutical online ordering kroger pharmacy refills online

  113. Lesterdoomy napsal:

    You stated it superbly.
    affordable drugs canada prescription price comparison are drugs from canada safe

  114. KeithBip napsal:

    Nicely put. Appreciate it!
    do prescription drugs have to be in original containers when flying prescriptions online super pharmacy

  115. Lesterdoomy napsal:

    Incredible loads of great material.
    is the canadian pharmacy legit nuvigil online canadian pharmacy national pharmacies online

  116. KeithBip napsal:

    Nicely put. Thanks!
    certified canadian drug stores singapore pharmacy store med pharmacy

  117. Williamkeymn napsal:

    Awesome write ups, Thank you!
    express scripts pharmacy bay rx pharmacy rx care pharmacy orlando fl

  118. Scottsix napsal:

    Thanks. Very good information!
    rx drugs in canada prescription cost medicine store pharmacy springfield, mo

  119. KeithBip napsal:

    Whoa plenty of beneficial data!
    topical rx pharmacy canadian pharmacy tramadol 300 er worst prescription drugs

  120. WilliamLuppy napsal:

    Helpful stuff. Thanks a lot.
    online pharmacy non prescription drugs pharmacy online cheap rate canadian pharmacies

  121. Scottsix napsal:

    Thank you, An abundance of posts.
    check canadian pharmacies website shoppers drug mart canada canadian pharmacy east bay largo fl

  122. KeithBip napsal:

    You made your point!
    online pharmacy fungal nail discount online canadian pharmacy vipps certified canadian pharmacies

  123. Josephabace napsal:

    Seriously many of valuable material!
    canadian pharmacy oxycodone legitimate canadian online pharmacies canada pharmacy online no script

  124. Thomasrot napsal:

    You said it nicely.!
    prescription drugs for anxiety rite aid pharmacy how many store how to get canadian pharmacy to stop calling

  125. Petereveva napsal:

    You have made your position extremely nicely!.
    canadian pharmacy delivery pharmacy store requirements purchase drugs from canada

  126. Josephabace napsal:

    Wonderful posts. Thanks a lot.
    zyban canadian pharmacy america rx pharmacy big mountain pharmacy in canada

  127. Thomasrot napsal:

    Cheers, Terrific stuff.
    cedarwood pharmacy canada pharmacy tech canada online canadian pharcharmy

  128. Petereveva napsal:

    Regards! Fantastic stuff.
    pharmacy online australia canadadrugs pharmacy buy drugs from canada legal

  129. RichardNus napsal:

    Terrific posts, Thank you!
    pharmacy drug store online no rx global pharmacy plus canada legal canadian online pharmacies

  130. Renaldoenala napsal:

    You said it perfectly..
    prescription drugs name importing prescription drugs from canada store locator cvs pharmacy

  131. KeithBip napsal:

    Regards. Ample tips!
    buy canadian drugs online pharmacy no prescription necessary rx crossroads pharmacy phone number

  132. RichardNus napsal:

    This is nicely said! .
    online pharmacy without insurance online canadian pharmacy ratings xalatan canadian pharmacy

  133. Justinediva napsal:

    Amazing all kinds of helpful info!
    global pharmacy canada problems super rx pharmacy pet meds canada pharmacy

  134. KeithBip napsal:

    Nicely voiced of course. .
    best online pharmacy india best drugstore eyeshadow best canadian mail order pharmacies

  135. Justinediva napsal:

    Superb material, Many thanks.
    pharmacy world canadian pharmacies drug prices online pharmacy uk

  136. KeithBip napsal:

    Regards. Great stuff!
    no prescription rx medicine online pharmacy delivery usa closest pharmacy store

  137. RobertRully napsal:

    Really quite a lot of fantastic info.
    online drugstore service canada online pharmacy delhi how to become a pharmacy technician online

  138. DouglasCreax napsal:

    Very good advice. Thanks!
    order canadian drugs misuse of prescription drugs what are the best online canadian pharmacies

  139. KeithBip napsal:

    Regards, Valuable information!
    online mail order pharmacy brooks pharmacy store locator botox canada pharmacy

  140. DavidItapY napsal:

    Fantastic facts. With thanks.
    international pharmacy no prescription giant eagle pharmacy hours is rx pharmacy coupons legit

  141. KeithBip napsal:

    Well expressed truly! .
    online meds no rx reliable kamagra oral jelly canadian pharmacy price checker

  142. KeithBip napsal:

    Nicely put. Thanks.
    my canadian pharmacy online pharmacy technician certification canada drug pharmacy online

  143. BrandonAlits napsal:

    Good facts. Kudos.
    online prescription drugs cheap drug prices best price cialis canadian pharmacy

  144. Aaronsaind napsal:

    Thanks a lot, Fantastic information!
    online pharmacy in usa virginia board of pharmacy mail order pharmacy no prescription

  145. Aaronsaind napsal:

    With thanks! Quite a lot of facts!
    buy prescription drugs in canada is canada pharmacy online legit mexico pharmacy order online

  146. MichaelNutty napsal:

    Amazing quite a lot of valuable information.
    ventolin canada pharmacy doctor prescription first medicine online pharmacy store discount code

  147. MichaelNutty napsal:

    Nicely put, Many thanks!
    canadian pharmacy viagra no prescription canadian viagra generic pharmacy canada drugs lp of canada

  148. Srzpyc napsal:

    oral levaquin 250mg order levaquin 250mg online cheap

  149. RogerWeele napsal:

    Nicely put, Cheers!
    largest canadian pharmacy oxycontin online pharmacy muscle relaxant

  150. Jamesorema napsal:

    Regards, Awesome stuff!
    buy mexican drugs online get canadian drugs cvs pharmacy in store coupons

  151. CharlesEcold napsal:

    Regards, Plenty of postings.
    how to apply at cvs pharmacy online canadian pharmacy in tampa fl canadian drugs northwest pharmacy

  152. Thomasrot napsal:

    You said it perfectly..
    pharmacy technician degree online sildenafil citrate canadian pharmacy 24 hour online pharmacy

  153. Thomasrot napsal:

    Nicely put, Kudos!
    abc pharmacy store locator canada drugs lawsuit vipps pharmacy in canada

  154. Fwfnse napsal:

    avodart without prescription order ondansetron 4mg order zofran 8mg online

  155. Josephbem napsal:

    Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
    ez rx pharmacy discount pharmacies narcotics online pharmacy

  156. Dlfohw napsal:

    aldactone us order aldactone 100mg sale buy diflucan 100mg pill

  157. JosephPaync napsal:

    Regards! Valuable information.
    good canadian pharmacy buy viagra pharmacy 100mg sky pharmacy online

  158. ChrisJaH napsal:

    Kudos! I enjoy this!
    canadian pharmacies that sell foley catheters national rx pharmacy best canadian pharmacy for viagra

  159. JosephPaync napsal:

    You’ve made your stand pretty effectively..
    what?s the best online pharmacy 77 canadian pharmacy pharmacy clothing store

  160. ThomasAxiof napsal:

    Really loads of wonderful material.
    aarp canadian pharmacies cialis canada online pharmacy canada drugs online review

  161. Ramiroriz napsal:

    You said that exceptionally well.
    humana mail order pharmacy prescription drugs become illegal when canada pharmacy generic cialis

  162. JamesClinc napsal:

    You have made your stand extremely nicely!!
    uk online pharmacy best online pharmacies without prescription canadian pharmacy 365 reviews

  163. Yvknmk napsal:

    order ampicillin 250mg pills buy cephalexin online buy erythromycin without prescription