7. 12. 2022

Ústavní soud: odsouzený má právo před zamítnutím podmíněného propuštění na vyjádření

foto: Ústavní soud

Okresní soud v Jablonci nad Nisou podmíněně propustil odsouzeného z výkonu trestu odnětí svobody, ale toto rozhodnutí bylo na základě stížnosti státní zástupkyně zrušeno Krajským soudem v Ústí nad Labem, který současně rozhodl, že se žádost odsouzeného o podmíněné propuštění zamítá. Krajský soud tak učinil, aniž by před rozhodnutím odsouzeného seznámil s textem stížnosti státní zástupkyně a aniž by mu poskytl možnost se k této stížnosti vyjádřit.

Proti tomu si odsouzený podal ústavní stížnost, které Ústavní soud vyhověl nálezem ze dne 8. 12. 2020, sp. zn. I. ÚS 2595/20. 

Ústavní soud tak učinil z důvodu porušení čl. 38 odst. 2 Listiny. Konkrétně uvedl, že také “v řízení o návrhu na podmíněné propuštění z výkonu trestu odnětí svobody je třeba dbát na dodržení kontradiktorních rysů řízení, mezi něž mj. patří princip rovnosti zbraní, možnost se znalostí věci vznášet argumenty ve svůj prospěch a vyvracet argumenty protistrany.” 

“Mezi neopominutelné prvky práva na spravedlivý (řádný) proces patří i zásada audiatur et altera pars (budiž vyslechnuta i druhá strana), jež je chápána jako povinnost soudu vytvořit prostor zaručující účastníkům řízení možnost účinně uplatňovat námitky a argumenty, které jsou způsobilé ovlivnit jeho rozhodování a s nimiž se soud musí v rozhodnutí náležitě vypořádat. Vytvoření prostoru pro účinné vznesení námitek (v kontradiktorním schématu řízení) totiž nejlépe zajišťuje ochranu základních práv; institucionálně garantovaná možnost dotčených osob návrhy a námitkami účinně participovat na soudním procesu přitom patří mezi elementární pravidla soudního řešení sporů.” 

Na základě výše uvedeného Ústavní soud shledal, že postupem krajského soudu došlo k porušení ústavně zaručeného práva stěžovatele tím, že stížnostní soud rozhodl o zamítnutí návrhu na podmíněné propuštění v neveřejném zasedání, aniž by stěžovatele předem seznámil s tvrzeními vznesenými druhou procesní stranou (s nimiž se posléze ztotožnil) a aniž by mu poskytl příležitost se k nim vyjádřit, případně navrhnout důkazy svědčící v jeho prospěch. 

Usnesení je dostupné zde.  

https://www.usoud.cz/fileadmin/user_upload/Tiskova_mluvci/Publikovane_nalezy/2021/I._US_2595_20_an.pdf

Diskuze (156) Vstoupit do diskuze

Vložit příspěvek

  1. Charlossaf napsal:

    You explained this well! https://definitionessays.com/ essay writers service

  2. Randymog napsal:

    Nicely put. Thanks a lot. essay writers wanted help thesis writing thesis help online

  3. Abrahamstore napsal:

    Great data. Thanks a lot. essay 123 help paper helper how to write a thesis

  4. AlvenBrigo napsal:

    Thank you. A good amount of tips!
    research dissertation how to be a good writer essay

  5. Alvinhig napsal:

    Very good info. Appreciate it!
    best essay services https://agbsl.pro/ research proposal writing service

  6. Wendellmon napsal:

    Many thanks! Quite a lot of forum posts!
    buy prescription drugs from canada visit poster’s website online pharmacy viagra

  7. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks, I appreciate this!
    custom essay writing service reviews https://orangepornhub.com/ how to write a community service essay

  8. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually expressed it very well!
    how to write a business essay help writing essay reliable essay writing service

  9. BruceZerce napsal:

    Nicely put. Thank you!
    canadian pharmacy world walmart pharmacy online viagra canada

  10. Wendellmon napsal:

    Nicely put, Appreciate it.
    pharmacy online prescription drugs canada navarro pharmacy

  11. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
    how to write an essay thesis https://flowleadsua.com/ cv writing services london

  12. Alvinhig napsal:

    Awesome info, Thanks!
    editing essay services essay about the help free writing help

  13. BruceZerce napsal:

    Nicely put, Thanks.
    canada pharma limited llc order medicine online canada drugs online

  14. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks, Lots of information!
    custom essays cheap essays writing services websites to type essays

  15. Alvinhig napsal:

    Thanks, Loads of information!
    what to write about in a college essay cite website in essay writers wanted online

  16. Wendellmon napsal:

    You made the point.
    prescription cost online canadian pharcharmy canada rx

  17. Alvinhig napsal:

    Wonderful info. Thank you.
    how to write essay for college application essays writer writing service level agreements

  18. Wendellmon napsal:

    You stated this perfectly!
    ordering prescriptions from canada legally safe canadian online pharmacies canada drugs online pharmacy

  19. Alvinhig napsal:

    You expressed that exceptionally well!
    how to write a paragraph essay https://agbsl.pro/ website writes essays for you

  20. BruceZerce napsal:

    With thanks, I enjoy this.
    buying prescription drugs canada canada pharmacy no prescription king pharmacy

  21. Alvinhig napsal:

    Amazing advice. Thanks a lot!
    buy essays online cheap essay typer phd proposal writing help

  22. Alvinhig napsal:

    Amazing material. With thanks!
    how to write an essay for college essays writer the best essay writing service

  23. Wendellmon napsal:

    You definitely made the point!
    canada drugs online pharmacy best canadian online pharmacy prescription online

  24. Alvinhig napsal:

    Helpful data. Regards.
    best essay writers writing an analytical essay cheapest article writing service

  25. BruceZerce napsal:

    Superb content. Regards!
    discount canadian drugs online medicine order discount online pharmacy viagra

  26. Alvinhig napsal:

    Superb stuff. Appreciate it!
    custom essay cheap writing compare and contrast essays the best writing service

  27. Wendellmon napsal:

    You explained this very well.
    cialis canada medication costs canadian drugstore

  28. Alvinhig napsal:

    Cheers. Loads of knowledge!
    how to write a good history essay https://homeworkcourseworkhelps.com/ law essay writing service

  29. Alvinhig napsal:

    You expressed this adequately.
    argumentative essay writing write my essay write my assignment ireland

  30. Alvinhig napsal:

    Valuable material. Thank you.
    prompts for college essays https://topswritingservices.com/ online custom writing services

  31. Alvinhig napsal:

    Terrific posts. Thank you.
    good college admission essays essays writer letter writing services

  32. Wendellmon napsal:

    You reported it effectively.
    generic viagra online pharmacy prescription cost comparison online pharmacy

  33. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks! I like this.
    how to write a college essay paper college essays nursing essay writing services

  34. BruceZerce napsal:

    You made your position quite nicely!.
    prescription pricing cheap canadian drugs prescription drugs prices

  35. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks. Great stuff.
    easy essay writing writing literary essays technical writing services

  36. Alvinhig napsal:

    Kudos! Terrific stuff!
    research essay help parts of essay writing website that writes your essay for you

  37. Wendellmon napsal:

    Useful facts. Cheers!
    ed meds online canadian rx pharmacy online modafinil online pharmacy

  38. Alvinhig napsal:

    Superb information, Thanks a lot.
    narrative college essay essays writer literature review writing services

  39. BruceZerce napsal:

    You stated this exceptionally well.
    mexican pharmacies online prescription drug cost canadian drug

  40. Alvinhig napsal:

    This is nicely expressed. .
    essay scholarships college students how to write the college essay write my annotated bibliography

  41. Alvinhig napsal:

    You suggested this wonderfully.
    writing a compare and contrast essay how to write a narrative essay introduction writers online

  42. Alvinhig napsal:

    You’ve made your point.
    college applications without essays https://quality-essays.com/ admission essay writing services

  43. Wendellmon napsal:

    Cheers. Wonderful information.
    canadian online pharmacies canadian drug drug price

  44. Alvinhig napsal:

    Very well expressed truly. .
    winning college essays how to write a 5 page essay help me write my thesis

  45. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks. A good amount of stuff.
    professional essay writing service essays about community service cheapest custom writing

  46. Wendellmon napsal:

    Wonderful stuff. Thanks!
    canada pharmacies/account pharmacy canada generic viagra online pharmacy

  47. BruceZerce napsal:

    Seriously quite a lot of valuable knowledge!
    canadian pharmacy drugs online pharmacie aarp approved canadian online pharmacies

  48. Alvinhig napsal:

    Appreciate it. Loads of content.
    best college essays ever https://altertraff.com/ articles writing service

  49. Alvinhig napsal:

    Whoa loads of superb material!
    professional essay writing services how to write an essay paper academic ghostwriter

  50. Wendellmon napsal:

    With thanks! Lots of tips!
    canadian pharmaceuticals online drugstore online canadian online pharmacy reviews

  51. BruceZerce napsal:

    You said it very well..
    canadian pharma companies online canadian pharmacy canadian drugs

  52. Alvinhig napsal:

    Wow a good deal of useful facts!
    essay writing on customer service essay writings all ivy writing services

  53. Alvinhig napsal:

    Terrific facts. Appreciate it!
    how to write descriptive essay how to write your college essay ghostwriting services

  54. Wendellmon napsal:

    Regards! Great stuff.
    canada drug prices buying drugs canada legal canadian prescription drugs online

  55. Alvinhig napsal:

    Incredible loads of amazing data.
    top essay writing services essays writing services write my summary

  56. Alvinhig napsal:

    Kudos, A good amount of content!
    how to write a reflective essay https://orangepornhub.com/ help writing a dissertation

  57. Alvinhig napsal:

    You said it very well.!
    how to write english essay write an essay for me the best essay writing services

  58. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put, Many thanks.
    writing a college admission essay essay help pros medical personal statement writing service

  59. BruceZerce napsal:

    Incredible loads of amazing knowledge.
    canada pharmacies prescription drugs prescription drugs without doctor approval cheap prescription drugs online

  60. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually suggested this superbly!
    best online essay editing service how to write reflection essay case study writers

  61. Alvinhig napsal:

    Excellent information. Thanks!
    cheap essay writers essaytyper cheap custom writing

  62. Alvinhig napsal:

    Thanks, Numerous material!
    yale college essay https://englishessayhelp.com/ cheap essay writing service

  63. BruceZerce napsal:

    Really all kinds of terrific knowledge!
    online pharmacy no prescription prescription drugs without prior prescription pharmacie canadienne

  64. Alvinhig napsal:

    Seriously plenty of very good material!
    generic college essay essaytyper resume and cover letter writing services

  65. Alvinhig napsal:

    Many thanks. An abundance of data.
    inspirational college essays https://service-essay.com/ best online resume writing services

  66. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually explained this fantastically.
    reflective essay help https://englishessayhelp.com/ professional writing website

  67. Wendellmon napsal:

    You actually suggested that exceptionally well.
    pharmacy northwest canada online pharmacies in usa canadian government approved pharmacies

  68. BruceZerce napsal:

    Truly a lot of terrific advice.
    canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy no prescription price pro pharmacy canada

  69. Alvinhig napsal:

    You’ve made your stand very clearly..
    how to write a english essay https://freshapps.space/ doctoral dissertation writing service

  70. Alvinhig napsal:

    Incredible loads of wonderful tips.
    steps on writing an essay https://essaypromaster.com/ executive resume writing service seattle

  71. Wendellmon napsal:

    You actually mentioned it effectively!
    canadian pharmacies-24h pain meds online without doctor prescription online pharmacy

  72. Alvinhig napsal:

    Kudos, Good stuff!
    college scholarships essays essay typer writing help

  73. BruceZerce napsal:

    Nicely put, Appreciate it.
    canadian pharmacy buy cialis canadian online pharmacy reviews

  74. Alvinhig napsal:

    Regards! Valuable stuff!
    essay on how to write an essay essay writing services mba essay writing services

  75. Wendellmon napsal:

    Thanks a lot, Ample facts!
    pharmacy price compare aarp recommended canadian pharmacies costco online pharmacy

  76. Alvinhig napsal:

    Awesome material, With thanks.
    college essays https://homeworkcourseworkhelps.com/ help for writing

  77. BruceZerce napsal:

    With thanks! Plenty of content.
    pharmacy price compare pharmacy intern canada pharmacies prescription drugs

  78. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually expressed this really well.
    mba essay editing service https://theessayswriters.com/ essay writing website reviews

  79. Alvinhig napsal:

    This is nicely said! !
    college essay community service how to write an argument essay hiring freelance writers

  80. Alvinhig napsal:

    You revealed this perfectly!
    how to write a good essay how to write an argumentative essay seo article writing service

  81. BruceZerce napsal:

    You actually said it terrifically!
    canadian pharmacy generic viagra canadian prescription drugstore canadian pharmacies without an rx

  82. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put. Cheers.
    transfer college essays essay writing service us medical school personal statement writing service

  83. Wendellmon napsal:

    Appreciate it. A good amount of knowledge!
    on line pharmacy buying drugs canada online pharmacy no prescription needed

  84. BruceZerce napsal:

    Nicely put, Thanks a lot.
    web medical information my canadian pharmacy order prescriptions online without doctor

  85. Alvinhig napsal:

    Truly all kinds of fantastic information!
    best essay review services college essay intro help with writing a dissertation

  86. Alvinhig napsal:

    Thanks a lot! Useful information!
    essay writer service https://orangepornhub.com/ best essay website

  87. Alvinhig napsal:

    Truly all kinds of beneficial data.
    website that writes essays write my essay need essay written

  88. Wendellmon napsal:

    Info clearly applied..
    prescription drugs online without discount pharmacies canada pharmacies online pharmacy

  89. BruceZerce napsal:

    You definitely made the point!
    canadian pharmacies without prescriptions walmart pharmacy viagra buying prescription drugs canada

  90. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put. With thanks.
    customized essay college essay web writing services

  91. Alvinhig napsal:

    Regards! Terrific stuff.
    essay writing services legal essay writing service best writing service websites

  92. Wendellmon napsal:

    Truly tons of great advice.
    cialis from canada trust pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies shipping to usa

  93. BruceZerce napsal:

    You stated it perfectly.
    trusted online pharmacy reviews pharmacy canada list of legitimate canadian pharmacies

  94. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put. Kudos!
    how to write an admission essay https://freshapps.space/ professional writing services rates

  95. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually explained it adequately.
    how to write an admissions essay for college essay writing service do my writing homework

  96. Alvinhig napsal:

    Nicely put. Kudos!
    how to write an admission essay https://topswritingservices.com/ professional essay writing service

  97. Wendellmon napsal:

    Wow tons of good knowledge.
    walgreens online pharmacy pharmacy online safeway pharmacy

  98. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually revealed this perfectly!
    how to write an essay response https://englishessayhelp.com/ essays websites

  99. BruceZerce napsal:

    Incredible plenty of very good data.
    drug costs canada pharmacy online no script best canadian mail order pharmacies

  100. Alvinhig napsal:

    Seriously quite a lot of very good tips.
    compare and contrast essay on high school and college essay web content writer

  101. Wendellmon napsal:

    Excellent knowledge. Thanks a lot!
    canadian pharmacy viagra brand cheap drugs online panacea pharmacy

  102. Alvinhig napsal:

    With thanks. Ample tips!
    help with writing essays write my essays report writing services

  103. Alvinhig napsal:

    Amazing information. Many thanks!
    custom essay cheap writing an illustration essay custom essay writing service

  104. Wendellmon napsal:

    Excellent advice. Regards!
    canadian pharmacy cialis 20mg list of approved canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies

  105. Alvinhig napsal:

    You said it adequately.!
    cheap essay writing service us easy essay writer creative writing websites for students

  106. BruceZerce napsal:

    You actually revealed that exceptionally well!
    costco online pharmacy pharmacy prices canadian discount pharmacy

  107. Alvinhig napsal:

    Very good information. With thanks.
    learning how to write an essay essay writer academic writing help

  108. Alvinhig napsal:

    Awesome content. Many thanks!
    what to write your college essay on https://essaypromaster.com/ help with dissertation writing

  109. Wendellmon napsal:

    You actually said this adequately!
    pharmacy online no prescription canadian meds canadian pharcharmy

  110. Alvinhig napsal:

    Cheers, I enjoy this.
    service learning reflection essay https://theessayswriters.com/ dissertation ghostwriter

  111. BruceZerce napsal:

    Regards, Quite a lot of info!
    canadian discount pharmacy discount prescription drugs online pills viagra pharmacy 100mg

  112. Alvinhig napsal:

    You actually explained that wonderfully!
    250 word college essay top essay writing services top essay writing services

  113. ChrisJaH napsal:

    Good information. Kudos.
    mail order drugs from canada alprazolam online pharmacy testosterone cream online pharmacy

  114. Renaldoenala napsal:

    With thanks, Plenty of stuff.

  115. KeithBip napsal:

    Excellent data. Many thanks!
    canada drug pharmacy coupon canadian pharmaceuticals online reviews rexall pharmacy & drug store

  116. ThomasAxiof napsal:

    Regards! I value this!
    canadian pharmacies mail order surrey bc canadian pharmacy com putney general store pharmacy

  117. KeithBip napsal:

    Kudos. Helpful stuff!
    coupon code for canada drugs which pharmacy is cheaper canada cvs pharmacy

  118. Wilfordben napsal:

    Wow all kinds of valuable data.
    reviews on canadian pharmacy online pharmacy hong kong best canadian pharmacy to buy from

  119. Antoniocrilm napsal:

    Terrific info. Thanks a lot!
    canadian pharmacy oxycodone legal online pharmacy coupon code most expensive common prescription drugs

  120. KeithBip napsal:

    Terrific postings, Regards!
    verified canadian pharmacy most trustworthy canadian pharmacy online pharmacy adipex

  121. Stanleyelumn napsal:

    Point very well applied!!
    best online pet pharmacy reviews pharmacy technician training program online rx pharmacy fords nj

  122. KeithBip napsal:

    Amazing a lot of great material!
    erectile enhancement pills online colleges for pharmacy tech visit poster’s website

  123. KeithBip napsal:

    You actually mentioned that well!
    zithromax canadian pharmacy nabp certified canadian pharmacy pharmacies with canadian drugs in lakeland fl

  124. RichardCit napsal:

    You actually said that terrifically.
    online pharmacies without prescription canadian pharmacy adipex canadian pharmacy asthma inhalers

  125. KeithBip napsal:

    Information very well regarded..
    rx city pharmacy viagra professional online pharmacy without precriptions

  126. Williamkeymn napsal:

    Superb data. Thanks.
    propecia online pharmacy the canadian pharmacy latisse canadian pharmacy

  127. Scottsix napsal:

    Cheers. A good amount of forum posts.
    legitimate canadian online pharmacy canadian pharmacy no prescription online pharmacy mail order

  128. KeithBip napsal:

    Superb stuff. Many thanks!
    hq pharmacy online 365 online pharmacy ordering prednisone canadian pharmacy

  129. Josephabace napsal:

    Incredible plenty of wonderful material.
    business plan for pharmacy store is rx pharmacy coupons legit canadian pharmacies that sell xaxax without prescriptions

  130. Thomasrot napsal:

    Nicely put. Cheers.
    drug costs verified canadian pharmacy online pharmacy australia paypal

  131. Petereveva napsal:

    Thank you. I appreciate this.
    buying prescription drugs online canadian pharmacies that ship to usa verified canadian pharmacies

  132. Renaldoenala napsal:

    Thanks. I value it!
    prescription cost global drugs direct canada kroger pharmacy store locator

  133. KeithBip napsal:

    You suggested this very well.
    rx pharmacy cards giant pharmacy store hours cialis generic pharmacy online

  134. RichardNus napsal:

    You actually stated it adequately!
    online pharmacy canada reviews canadian pharmacy venice fl pharmacy rx one coupon

  135. Justinediva napsal:

    Position clearly regarded!!
    america rx pharmacy best online pharmacy for generic viagra is it legal to buy drugs from canada

  136. KeithBip napsal:

    Thanks a lot, An abundance of material.
    safe canadian online pharmacies global canadian pharmacy canadian meds without a script

  137. DouglasCreax napsal:

    Very good info, Thank you!
    canadian animal pharmacy mobile rx pharmacy rite aid pharmacy store locations

  138. DavidItapY napsal:

    You revealed it well.
    most expensive prescription drugs what are the best online canadian pharmacies safe reliable canadian pharmacy

  139. KeithBip napsal:

    Superb write ups. Regards!
    publix pharmacy store locator canadian overnight pharmacy review online pharmacy tech schools

  140. BrandonAlits napsal:

    Many thanks. An abundance of stuff!
    rx canada pharmacy legit canadian pharmacy mobile pharmacy canada

  141. Aaronsaind napsal:

    Many thanks. Quite a lot of forum posts!
    kex rx pharmacy atchison ks california board of pharmacy virginia board of pharmacy

  142. MichaelNutty napsal:

    You suggested that superbly.
    rx city pharmacy pharmacy price compare fda approved canadian online pharmacies

  143. Jamesorema napsal:

    Really tons of superb information.
    navarro pharmacy erectile pills without a doctor prescription online medicine shopping

  144. Ernestgex napsal:

    Appreciate it! Ample write ups.
    canadian pharmacy viagra cialis trustworthy canadian pharmacy pharmacy online canada

  145. CharlesEcold napsal:

    You definitely made your point.
    dispose of prescription drugs drugs without a doctor s prescription online pharmacy fungal nail

  146. Thomasrot napsal:

    Great facts. With thanks.
    walmart pharmacy near me coupon code for canada drugs prescription prices comparison

  147. ChrisJaH napsal:

    Appreciate it! Ample knowledge.
    visit poster’s website walmart pharmacy store number sangani canada drugs direct reviews

  148. Ibuqcc napsal:

    dutasteride oral zofran 8mg generic ondansetron 8mg generic

  149. Umxtqa napsal:

    spironolactone generic buy valtrex 1000mg online cheap fluconazole 200mg cost

  150. ThomasAxiof napsal:

    You made your position very clearly!!
    buy prescriptions online pharmacy online cheap testosterone canadian pharmacy

  151. Mjyhyc napsal:

    ampicillin buy online acillin usa buy erythromycin 500mg online

  152. Antoniocrilm napsal:

    Regards! Good stuff.
    xanax from canadian pharmacy kroger pharmacy store locator canadian pharmacy comparison

  153. Dwaynedob napsal:

    With thanks! A good amount of content.
    publix pharmacy store hours pharmacy canadian legit online pharmacy

  154. Davidnum napsal:

    You explained this fantastically!
    canadian pharmacy cialis 5mg canadian pharmacies compare canadian drugs without prescription